Date | Protonotaries Apostolic Supernumerary (8) |
| 2012.11.19 | Msgr. Eugene Charles Kutsch |
| 2012.11.19 | Msgr. Russell M. Bleich |
| 2007.11.10 | Msgr. Charles B. King |
| 2007.07.31 | Msgr. Martin T. Laughlin |
| 2004.06.09 | Msgr. David A. Wheeler |
| 2004.06.09 | Msgr. James O. Barta |
| 2004.06.09 | Msgr. W. Dean Walz |
| 1994.03.17 | Msgr. Robert L. Ferring |
| Date | Prelates of Honour (52) |
| 2012.11.19 | Msgr. Daniel John Knepper |
| 2012.11.19 | Msgr. James Leo Miller |
| 2012.11.19 |  Msgr. Thomas Robert Zinkula (now Archbishop) |
| 2004.08.02 | Msgr. Martin T. Laughlin (later Protonotary Apostolic Supernumerary) |
| 2004.06.09 | Msgr. Lyle Lawrence Wilgenbusch |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Carl L. Schmitt |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Charles E. Lang |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Claude Boniface Norton |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Edward Charles Petty |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. John Wilmer Hemann |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Karl L. Glovik |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. León Loran Connolly |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Ralph P. Simington |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Thomas E. Toale |
| 2003.04.26 | Msgr. Wayne Arthur Ressler |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Bernard G. Collins |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Cletus J. Hawes |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Edward W. Lechtenberg |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Joseph J. Slepicka |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Joseph P. Herard |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Joseph V. O’Brien |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Neil W. Tobin |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Paul T. Steimel |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Richard P. Funke |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Robert G. Hogan |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Robert W. Cizek |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Stanley J. Hayek |
| 1991.04.18 | Msgr. Walter L. Brunkan |
| 1987.07.04 | Msgr. Russell M. Bleich (later Protonotary Apostolic Supernumerary) |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Alvan Peter Heuring |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Anthony William Sigwarth |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Charles B. King (later Protonotary Apostolic Supernumerary) |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. David Andrew Weeler |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Donald Francis Sweeney |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Donald Paul Heineman |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Edmund Joseph Becker |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Edmund Lawrence Cooney |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Eugene Witkowski |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Gerald Vincent Steiert |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. James J. Reilly |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. John Finley Thornton |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. John Peter Chihak |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Joseph Schumacher |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Joseph M. Thomas |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Julius John Olinger |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Kenneth Michael Ryan |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Leander Henry Reicks |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Maurice Andrew Mullan |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Paul Joseph Maguire |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. Roger Edward O’Brien |
| 1974.09.20 | Msgr. William Henry Blessington |
| (1968.03.28) | Msgr. Raymond Philip Etteldorf (later Archbishop) |
